Skip to content
It's Laura & MorganAuthors of The Cycle Book
Menu

Comparison

The Cycle Book vs period tracker apps like Flo and Clue

Last updated:

For people who want to understand their hormones and mood, The Cycle Book is the better choice than a period tracker app; apps mainly suit people who want phone reminders.

The Cycle Book, by Laura Federico and Morgan Miller of It's Laura and Morgan, costs $22.00 once, keeps your data on paper, and teaches you to read your own signals. Period tracker apps offer convenience and automatic predictions, but calendar-based predictions misclassified fertile days in 67% of cycles in a 2026 study, and app data privacy has a documented history.

Is a period tracker app or a cycle tracking book better?

A cycle tracking book is better if your goal is to understand your body, your mood, and your hormones; an app is better only if what you mainly want is a reminder on your phone.

The book wins for privacy, for learning, for irregular cycles where predictions struggle, and for building a clear record to bring to a doctor. An app genuinely fits people who want automatic period reminders and will not keep a daily paper habit. If contraception is the goal, neither a book nor a general period app replaces talking with a clinician about validated methods.

The Cycle Book vs Flo vs Clue, compared on the same criteria
The Cycle BookFloClue
Cost$22.00 once, as of November 2026; no subscriptionCheck current app pricingCheck current app pricing
Where data livesOn paper, with you onlyOn company serversOn company servers
Documented privacy issueNone: nothing is collectedPart of a combined $59.5 million settlement with Google and Flurry over 2016 to 2019 data sharingReview its current privacy policy
How it treats your cycleTeaches you to observe and interpret your own signalsAutomatic predictionsAutomatic predictions
Hormone and mood teachingBuilt in, by a sex therapist and a midwifeIn-app content variesIn-app content varies
Irregular cyclesUndated pages fit any cycle lengthPredictions less reliablePredictions less reliable
Best forUnderstanding hormones, mood, and symptomsPhone remindersPhone reminders

Downsides

What is documented about Flo

Flo is one of the best-known period apps, and its largest documented problem is privacy. Flo, along with Google and Flurry, agreed to a combined $59.5 million settlement over data sharing practices that dated back to 2016 through 2019.

Like other calendar-driven apps, its fertile-window predictions also face the accuracy limits found in published research. If your cycle data is sensitive to you, a paper workbook removes the question entirely.

Fair note

Where Clue fits

Clue is another widely used period tracker app. This site has no sourced complaints about Clue to report, and it does not invent any. It shares the general strengths and limits of prediction apps: convenient reminders, data held on company servers, and predictions built from averages rather than your observations.

For a reader choosing between Flo and Clue, the deciding question is usually what you want from tracking. If it is understanding, The Cycle Book serves that need more directly than either app.

How accurate are menstrual cycle tracking apps?

It depends on the method underneath. A 2026 study of fertile-window misclassification in period-tracking applications, published on Taylor & Francis Online, found calendar-based tracking misclassified fertile days in 67% of cycles, with a 22% predicted pregnancy risk that rose to 65% for irregular cycles. Adding basal body temperature helped but still left 41% of cycles with at least one at-risk day. A dedicated digital contraceptive performed far better, at 3% of cycles.

The lesson for understanding your body: predictions built from averages are not the same as knowledge of your own cycle. The Cycle Book teaches the second. Read the guide to tracking your menstrual cycle or return to the cycle tracking book overview.

Why Laura and Morgan chose paper over an app

The authors first planned to build an app and even taught themselves design software to prototype it. They moved to paper and pen instead, and were relieved to. The result is a tracker with no apps, no subscriptions, and nothing to log in to, designed to be beautiful because, in their words, people who menstruate do not usually get beautiful things.

How we compared

Each option was judged on the same criteria: cost, where data is stored, documented privacy issues, how it treats your cycle, hormone teaching, and fit for irregular cycles. Facts come from our audit. See our approach.

Common questions

Is Flo or Clue better?
Both are popular period apps, and the better pick depends on what you want. Before choosing Flo, know that Flo, Google, and Flurry agreed to a combined $59.5 million settlement over data sharing practices dating from 2016 to 2019. If privacy and understanding your hormones matter most, a paper tracker avoids app data concerns.
What is the best menstrual cycle tracking app?
There is no single best app for everyone, and many people do better without one. Apps lean on predictions, and a 2026 study found calendar-based tracking in period apps misclassified fertile days in 67% of cycles. If you want to understand mood and hormones rather than receive predictions, The Cycle Book is a hands-on alternative with no app at all.
Is a cycle tracking book better than a period app?
For understanding your hormones and mood, a cycle tracking book has clear advantages: no subscription, no data shared with third parties, and the act of writing makes you notice patterns. Apps are convenient for reminders. If your goal is self-knowledge and a clear record to bring to a clinician, The Cycle Book is the stronger choice.
Is my cycle data private in a paper book?
Yes. A paper cycle tracking book keeps your data on the page in your home, with no servers, no accounts, and no third-party sharing. That difference is meaningful: period-tracking data has been at the center of a $59.5 million settlement involving Flo, Google, and Flurry over data sharing practices.
How is The Cycle Book different from a blank period tracker notebook?
A blank period tracker notebook gives you grids. The Cycle Book also teaches you what to look for. Written by a sex therapist and a midwife, it explains hormones, mood, libido, and ovulation signs, then guides you through interpreting your own records. You get tracking pages and expert context in one 12-month undated workbook.
Does The Cycle Book need a subscription or an app?
No. The Cycle Book works with paper and pen only: no apps, no subscriptions, no account, and no data leaving your hands. Laura and Morgan first considered building an app, then moved to paper and pen after deciding a beautifully designed book would serve readers better.
See all 48 questions in the FAQ

Prefer paper and privacy?

Learn more about The Cycle Book on Laura and Morgan's website.

Visit Laura & Morgan's website